The documentary poses the theory that Magnotta made him up, inspired by the film Basic Instinct. The jury rejected this defense and there is no evidence that he even exists. The documentary reveals that Magnotta did seek help and repeatedly claimed that he had been manipulated and abuse for most of his life by a mysterious figure named Manny Lopez, who Magnotta says forced him to commit every crime he was accused of. Magnotta received the same diagnosis five years later, which led him to drop out of high school. He reportedly mentioned his family's history with paranoid schizophrenia, with his father receiving a diagnosis for the condition in 1994. There is more to Luka Magnotta's history of mental illness than Don't F**k With Cats shows. As noted by the Montreal Gazette, one month before he killed Lin Jun, Magnotta went to the Jewish General Hospital where he told a psychiatrist he couldn’t sleep, and was feeling impulsive and irritable. The documentary even implies that Magnotta's act of murder, and his subsequent questioning, were an elaborate homage to one of his favourite movies, Basic Instinct. There is a reason for this: How do you fairly and empathetically discuss a convicted killer's mental health when he has spent most of his life lying about himself and manipulating others with said mistruths? Don’t F**k With Cats seems firmly of the opinion that Magnotta is either making up his mental issues or greatly exaggerating them so as to be able to claim diminished responsibility during his trial. Magnotta's mental health is briefly discussed in the documentary but with a heavily skeptical slant from the narrative. Not much is revealed about his childhood, even in moments where his mother, Anna Yourkin, discusses and defends him the filmmakers include a brief clip of Yourkin discussing Magnotta being bullied as a child, as well as his love of movies. The documentary does not mention that Luka Magnotta is not his real name (he legally changed it in 2006), although his various aliases are discussed. Magnotta was born Eric Clinton Kirk Newman On July 24, 1982. Given the controversy of the case itself and the need for sensitivity in discussing it, it’s no wonder that Don’t F**k With Cats garnered so much criticism for its depressingly ham-fisted approach to the story and decision to show some of the footage Magnotta recorded of his torturous and murderous misdeeds. The documentary at first focuses on the investigative work done to find Magnotta and the wider ramifications of such work before moving its focus more onto Magnotta himself. Before the authorities would listen to them, however, Magnotta killed and dismembered Chinese student Lin Jun, an act he also filmed himself committing. These clips quickly went viral and a group of amateur online sleuths took it upon themselves to track Magnotta down and bring him to justice. Magnotta is one of the most infamous criminals in modern Canadian history, an aspiring male model and part-time escort who demanded the world’s attention via films he made of himself torturing and killing kittens. Related: The Biggest Lies In Scorsese/Netflix's Bob Dylan Documentary This always comes with its own set of problems, and that’s evident with the Magnotta case, a strange and deeply disturbing story that must be handled with care. Don't F**k With Cats is similarly drawing criticism for its depiction of horrific images, as well as its treatment of mental illness. As with all true crime documentaries, elements are condensed for time or not included in the wider retelling. The 2018 series Evil Genius garnered headlines for deciding to show audiences the moment a man died after a bomb around his throat detonated, as well as its depiction of the accused killer's mental illness. Making a Murderer became a hot-button topic, leading audiences and legal experts to argue over how biased the filmmakers’ stances were regarding a difficult case. Don't F**k With Cats is not the first Netflix original true-crime documentary to cause controversy.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |